Some emojis don't appear when using hide-if or show-if macros
Some emojis look fine when page is published, but they appear as blue stars when the same page is used in a Live Template macro.
This is caused by an issue in Confluence which is affecting Visibility and a number of other apps.
Stop using Confluence editor emojis and use the built-in emojis found in many OSes:
In Windows 10: Use the emoji keyboard - press the Windows logo key + . (period). The emoji keyboard will appear.
In Mac OS: Use the character viewer.
Currently listed as a bug by Atlassian. No timeline has been provided for fixing this bug.